The seed for this collection of superlight mountain bikes was planted when Kestrel offered us its most exotic composite monocoque frameset, the CS–X EMS, outfitted with a wish list of gossamer componentry at a weight of less than 20 pounds. I said the same thing you would: Yes, please.
For a year I´d been riding a steel–frame KHS mountain bike whittled to 22 pounds by parts swapping, so I knew lightness wasn´t the exclusive domain of composite technology. Thus, I chose an aluminum Klein, titanium McMahon, and steel Steelman to represent the other commonly used frame materials and fill out the test.
They have stiff competition (figuratively and literally) because the Kestrel is as impressively rigid as it is light, with reasonable comfort to boot. Up front, there´s the smooth resilience of the Ritchey Logic chrome-moly unicrown fork, which flexes visibly without feeling squirrelly. The frame´s subtle smoothness comes not from flexing tubes—the Kestrel´s don´t, to any significant degree—but from their shock´eating composite layers. Vibration is stopped, not passed to the rider.
There are lots of ways to make a sweet–riding bike, but when minimal weight is desired it´s tough to beat the combination of composites and monocoque construction. The various "tube" shapes (technically, the frame is one piece) triangulate and reinforce each member against specific forces. This compliments composites´ strength–in–tension properties, allowing the orientation of structural fibers to subdue the stresses of each location. There´s no need for extra material, as with metals.
So much for theory. The proof, as they say, is in the pedalin´, and the EMS saw a lot of action under me and technical editor Fred Zahradnik in Pennsylvania and Colorado. Most impressive to Dr. Z was the lack of flex at the bottom bracket, along the top tube, and at the rear brake bosses. Yet the Frame weighs just 3.25 pounds, and the bike is an incredible 19.65 pounds. Being a care–ful, smooth rider, Fred didn´t drop off a cliff or broadside any aspens while in Crested Butte, but he remembers hearing a couple large rocks whack the down tube during descents.
Kestrel sent the EMS with 172.5–mm Ritchey cranks, the same length Fred rides on road. Although I prefer longer ones off road, Fred says they didn´t hinder his climbing ability. Not so the gearing—an optimistic 13–24T SunTour steel freewheel, which he eventually swapped for a wider range. The irony is, Kestrel chose such esoteric weight savers as squishy–feeling CLB aluminum alloy brake cable housing, and used alloy brake cable adjuster barrels in place of allen–bolt brake fixing bolts, yet missed a chance to come half a pound closer to the elusive 19–pound barrier by installing a Campagnolo alloy Cluster (not the most durable off–road cogs, but no less realistic than a 24T low). Also absent was the lighter, WCS version of the Ritchey Force tires, which, with the Campy block, would certainly have put the bike at 19 pounds (see "Lighter Than Lite," page 123).
Kestrel recovered nicely, in my book, with the lightness and beauty of the polished titanium stem, handmade by Arctos Machine´s